Legal Bases for Prosecution of Medical Staff for Illegal Acts During the Soviet and Post-Soviet Periods

Objective: to study the historical retrospective of the Soviet (1917-1991) and post-Soviet (1991 – present) periods of healthcare, the evolution of their legal support; to conduct a comprehensive criminological study and analysis of the criminal liability of medical staff who committed illegal acts in the historical periods under consideration.

Methods: the methodological basis of the study was the methods of analysis, synthesis, comparison, formal and logical approach. In addition, the author used specific scientific methods, including the historical one.

Results: in general, the analysis of the legal foundations of criminal prosecution of medical staff who committed illegal acts during the Soviet and post-Soviet period suggests that the institute of legal liability of medical staff, the medical science and practice developed in parallel under the influence of social, economic and political factors. Since the beginning of the Soviet period, the issues of liability of medical staff have caused numerous disputes among both researchers and practitioners, and today these disputes continue and do not subside. At the same time, it is important to emphasize that the Russian legislative system in the field of healthcare has always been formed solely with the special attitude of the state and society to medical staff, who were perceived as guardians of the health of the citizens and enjoyed their confidence, which in turn gave rise to special caution and responsibility among medical personnel.

Scientific novelty: the study is distinguished by the author’s unique approach, which allowed stating the social conditionality of legal prohibitions for the illegal acts under consideration, as well as the causal relationship between the regulatory legal framework formed and the social consequences generated by it in the Soviet and post-Soviet periods.

Practical significance: the conclusions obtained by studying the genesis of the problems related to the liability of medical personnel for committing illegal acts will contribute to the development of a scientific understanding of the essence of the phenomenon under consideration, as well as the identification of a modern causal complex contributing to the occurrence of these illegal acts.

1. Shilyuk, T. S. (2010). Administrative-legal regulation in the sphere of healthcare, abstract of a PhD (Law) thesis. Moscow (in Russ.).

2. Chefranov, K. A. (2020). Criminal liability of medical personnel for causing harm or death to health of patients in providing medical care: historical aspect. Bulletin of Ufa Law Institute of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, 3 (89), 57–63 (in Russ.).

3. Abuladze, D. A. (1931). On the judicial liability of a doctor. Tiflis (in Russ.).

4. Brusilovckii, A. E., Levin, A. M. (1930). Medical errors by judicial materials. Kharkov, Yuridicheskoe izdatel'stvo NKYu UCCR (in Russ.).

5. Brushtein, S. A. (1930). Errors in diagnostics and therapy. Moscow; Leningrad: Gosudarstvennoe izdatelstvo (in Russ.).

6. Gusev, A. D. (1935). Medical errors and medical crimes. Kazanskii meditsinskii zhurnal, 6, 686–708 (in Russ.).

7. Gubarev, A. P. (1927). On the judicial liability of a doctor. Moscow (in Russ.).

8. Davydovskii, I. V. (1941). Medical errors. Sovetskaya meditsina, 3, 3–10 (in Russ.).

9. Leibovich, Ya. L. (1926). Judicial liability of doctors. Leningrad; Moscow, Rabochii sud (in Russ.).

10. Malis, Yu. G. (1926). Criminal liability of doctors. Pravo i zhizn. Moscow. Book 1 (in Russ.).

11. Raiskii, M. I. (1929). Liability of a doctor. Voprosy zdravookhraneniya, 1, 8–22 (in Russ.).

12. Sapozhnikov, Yu. S. (1932). On liability of a doctor for professional errors. Kiev 52 (in Russ.).

13. Adrianov, A. D. (1957). Etiology of a criminal abortion. In Collection of scientific works of eth Department members and forensic dooctors of Leningrad, 10, 94–106 (in Russ.).

14. Baikovskii, S. B. (1959). Doctors’ cases. Voprosy teorii i praktiki sudebnoi meditsiny, 71–78 (in Russ.).

15. Budak, T. A. (1957). Doctors’ cases by the materials of the Bureau of the Chief Office of Forensic Expertise. In Sbornik nauchnykh statei Odesskogo otdeleniya UNOSMiK. Odessa (in Russ.).

16. Vermel, I. G. (1967). On logical errors in judicial-medical conclusions. Sudebno-meditsinskaya ekspertiza, 1, 26–30 (in Russ.).

17. Neuvazhaev, A. I. (1965). On the expertise of doctors’ cases. Sudebno-meditsinskaya ekspertiza i kriminalistika na sluzhbe sledstviya: sbornik rabot, 4, 65–72 (in Russ.).

18. Ogarkov, I. F. (1966). Medical offences and criminal liability for them. Leningrad, Meditsina (in Russ.).

19. Sidorov, S. M. (1954). On medical “errors”: collection of reviews and abstracts of Kazakh State edical University for 1932–1952. Alma-Ata (in Russ.).

20. Edel, Yu. P. (1956). On sending the materials on doctors’ cases for forensic expertise. In Sbornik nauchnykh rabot po sudebnoi meditsine i kriminalistike, posvyashchennyi pamyati prof. I. S. Bokariusa. Kharkov (in Russ.).

21. Glushkov, V. A. (1984). On the liability of medical staff for negligent violation of professioal duties. Klinicheskaya khirurgiya, 12, 32–34 (in Russ.). 22. Gromov, A. P. (1969). Medical deontology and liability of medical staff. Moscow, Meditsina (in Russ.).

22. Grando, A. A. (1988). Doctors’ ethics and medical deontology. Kiev, Vishcha shkola (in Russ.).

23. Kontsevich, I. A. (1983). Duty and liability of a doctor. Kiev (in Russ.).

24. Petrov, B. D. (1972). A doctor, patients, and health people. Moscow, Meditsina (in Russ.).

25. Savitskaya, A. N. (1982). Reimbursing the harm inflicted by improper treating. Lvov (in Russ.).

26. Sergeev, Yu. D. (1988). The doctor’s profession: juridical bases. Kiev, Vysshaya shkola (in Russ.).

27. Smitienko, V. N. (1989). Criminal-legal health protection in the USSR, monograph. Kiev, Vishcha shk. Golovnoe izd-vo (in Russ.).

28. Sukhoverkhii, V. L. (1975). Civil-legal regulation of relations in the sphere of healthcare. Sovetskoe gosudarstvo i parvo, 6, 105–109 (in Russ.).

29. Yaroshenko, K. B. (1970). Property liability of medical institutions for the harm inflicted by their employees. Voprosy gosudarstva i prava, 2, 247–254 (in Russ.).

30. Bedrin, L. M. (1994). On the rights of medical employees and their liability for inflicting harm on citizens’ health. Novosti meditsiny i farmatsii, 2, S. 27–28 (in Russ.).

31. Gladun, Z. S. (1994). Legislation on healthcare: issues of forming a new theoretical model. Gosudarstvo i parvo, 2, 116–122 (in Russ.).

32. Maleina, M. N. (1995). Man and medicine in modern law, tutorial and practice book. Moscow, Bek (in Russ.).

33. Sergeev, V. V. et al. (2000). Juridical analysis of professional errors of medical staff. Samara, Sokol-T (in Russ.).

34. Ballo, A. M., Ballo, A. A. (2001). Rights of patients and liability of medical staff for the harm inflicted. Saint Petersburg, BiS (in Russ.).

35. Viter, V. I., Dimov, A. S., Volkova, O. A. (2011). On elaborating the methodology of researching the deontological aspect of doctors’ activity (methodological substantiation and practice of specific research). In Forensic medicine and medical law: Topical issues: works of a scientific-practical conference with international participation in the memory of an Honored Researcher of the Russian Federation, Professor G. A. Pashinyan. Moscow (in Russ.).

36. Golyshev, A. Ya., Rozhkov, N. N. (2008). Quality of medical services as an object of qualimetric evaluation. Menedzher zdravookhraneniya, 7, 40–44 (in Russ.).

37. Kvernadze, R. A. (2001). Some aspects of formation and development of healthcare law, State and Law, 8 , 99–104 (in Russ.).

38. Kolokolov, G. R. (2009). Protection of rights of patients. Ser. Narodnyi yurist. Moscow, GrossMedia, ROSBUKh (in Russ.).

39. Mokhov, A. A., Mokhova, I. N. (2006). Functions of liabilities due to inflicting harm to health or life of a patient. Meditsinskoe parvo, 3, 35–38 (in Russ.).

40. Sitdikova, L. B. (2010). Legal criteria for estimating the quality of medical services. Meditsinskoe parvo, 4, 22–26 (in Russ.).

41. Suchkov, A. V. (2008). The juridical problems of interrelations between medical staff and patients. Pravovye problemy vzaimootnosheniya meditsinskikh rabotnikov i patsientov pri sovershenii medikami professional'nykh pravonarushenii. Medical Newsletter of Vyatka, 3–4, 77–79 (in Russ.).

42. Sergeev, Yu. D., Kanunnikova, L. V. (2007). Improper rendering of medical services and risk factors for its broadening. Meditsinskoe parvo, 4, 3–6 (in Russ.).

43. Suchkova, T. E. (2011). Administrative liability of nedical staff for improper execution of professional duties, Meditsinskoe parvo, 4, 48–56 (in Russ.).

44. Sheregova, F. (2009). Protection of the righhts of citizens for medical aid. Zakonnost, 2, 57–59 (in Russ.).

45. Barinov, E. Kh., Sundukov, D. V., Romodanovskii, P. O. et al. (2020). Criminal libility for the crimes related to violation of professional duties by medical staff [Ugolovnaya otvetstvennost' za prestupleniya, svyazannye s narusheniem meditsinskimi rabotnikami professional'nogo dolga]. Moscow, Rossiiskii universitet druzhby narodov (RUDN) (in Russ.).

46. Bimbinov, A. A. (2019). Medical offences: concept and condition. Law Нerald of Dagestan State University, 32 (4), 136–140 (in Russ.). DOI: https://doi.org/10.21779/2224-0241-2019-32-4-136-140

47. Galyukova, M. I. (2008). Features of criminal libility of medical staff for inflicting harm to human health, tutorial. Omsk, Omskaya akad. MVD Rossii (in Russ.).

48. Kibal'nik, A. G., Starostina, Ya. V. (2006). Topical issues of criminal libility of medical staff, monograph. Moscow, Ileksa (in Russ.).

49. Kolokolov, A. V. (2020). Issues of juridical qualification of improper rendering of medical aid. Sud'ya, 2 (110), 18–22 (in Russ.).

50. Ognerubov, N. A. (2018). Criminal liability of medical staff for inflicting harm to patients’ life and health: theory and practice, monograph. Tambov, Derzhavinskii (in Russ.).

51. Paulava, L. V. (2021). Criminal liability of health professionals as special subjects: to the question of the development of medical criminal law. Siberian Criminal Process and Criminalistic Readings, 2 (32), 11–21 (in Russ.).

52. Serebrennikova, A. V. (2021). Criminal responsibility of medical professionals: discussion issues. Sociopolitical Sciences, 1, 53-58. (in Russ.).

53. Trunov I. L. (2009). Medical error: a crime or an offense? Predstavitel'naya vlast' – XXI vek: zakonodatel'stvo, kommentarii, problem, 2–3 (89–90), 20–25 (in Russ.).

54. Vardyanyan, G. D., Avetisyan, G. A., Dzhanonyan, G. Dzh. et al. (2019). Medical errors: actual state of the issue. Meditsinskaya nauka Armenii, 59 (4), 105–120 (in Russ.).

55. Onetti, Marco, Cirillo, Pasquale, Musile Tanzi, Paola, Trinchero Elisabetta. (2016). An Analysis of the Number of Medical Malpractice Claims and Their Amounts. Plos One, 11 (4). DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0153362

56. Negodov, V. E. (2012). Legal regulation of organization and managing the processes of healthcare modernization in the Russian Federation, abstract of a PhD (Law) thesis. Moscow (in Russ.).

57. Elina, N. K. (2006). Legal aspects of rendering medical services, abstract of a PhD (Law) thesis. Volgogr. akad. MVD Rossii. Volgograd (in Russ.).

58. Zhamkova, O. E. (2007). Legal regulation of rendering medical services by the legislation of the Russian Federation, abstract of a PhD (Law) thesis. Mosk. un-t MVD RF. Moscow (in Russ.).

59. Maleina, M. N. (1985). Legal regulation of relations between citizens and medical institutions (Civil-legal aspect) Правовое, PhD (Law) thesis. Moscow (in Russ.).

60. Kosolapova, N. V. (2000). Constitutional provision of the right of citizens for medical aid, abstract of a PhD (Law) thesis. Saratov. (in Russ.).

61. Lesnichenko, E. N. (2010). Improving the institutional conditions and tools for rendering medical services, PhD (Economics) thesis. Krasnodar (in Russ.).

62. Starostina, Ya. V. (2005). Issues of criminal liability of medical staff, abstract of a PhD (Law) thesis. Stavrop. gos. un-t. Stavropol (in Russ.).

63. Murav'eva, E. V. (2004). Civil-legal liability in the sphere of medical activity, abstract of a PhD (Law) thesis. Rostov on Don (in Russ.).

64. Abdullina, V. S. (2007). Civil-legal liability for violations in the sphere of rendering medical services: some issues of theory and practice, PhD (Law) thesis. Kazan (in Russ.).

65. Priz, E. V. (2011). Social complementarity of the rights of patients and medical staff in the Russian healthcare system, abstract of a PhD (Medicine) thesis. Volgograd (in Russ.).

66. Sagalaeva, E. S. (2007). Legal regulation of rendering medical services to the underaged, abstract of a PhD (Law) thesis. Moscow (in Russ.).

67. Zal'munin, Yu. S. (1950). Medical errors and doctors’ liability (by the materials of Leningrad forensic medical examination office), PhD (Medicine) thesis. Leningrad (in Russ.).

68. Sidorovich, Yu. S. (2005). Civil-legal liability for a medical error, abstract of a PhD (Law) thesis. Moscow (in Russ.).

69. Chervonnykh, E. V. (2009). Crimes committed in the sphere of healthcare and their prevention, abstract of a PhD (Law) thesis. Saratov (in Russ.).

70. Decree of the Council of the People’s Commissariate of the Russian Soviet Federal Socialist Republic of 18.07.1918 “On the People’s Commissariate for Healthcare (Proviiosn)”. http://www.consultant.ru/cons/cgi/online.cgi?req=doc&base=ESU&n=18546#0dPzsiSx9IVCGWcc (access date: 10.10.2021) (in Russ.).

71. Davydova, T. V. (2015). Soviet legislation on healthcare in the pre-war period (1917–1941): historical and legal aspect. Tambov University Review. Series: Humanities, 20, 11 (151), 79–85 (in Russ.). https://doi.org/10.20310/1810-0201-2015-20-11(151)-79-85

72. Decree of the Council of the RSFSR People’s Commissariate of 23.01.1918 “On separating church from the state and school from church”. http://www.consultant.ru/cons/cgi/online.cgi?req=doc&base=ESU&n=1777#FvuzsiS4IGvGaMQl (access date: 10.10.2021) (in Russ.).

73. Mironova, N. A. (2009). Typhus Epidemic in Yaroslavl in 1919. Yaroslavl Pedagogical Bulletin, 2 (59), 244–247 (in Russ.).

74. Decree of the All-Russian Central Executive Committee, Council of the RSFSR People’s Commissariate of 01.12.1924 (edition of 29.12.1971) “On professional work and rights of medical staff”. http://www.consultant.ru/cons/cgi/online.cgi?req=doc&base=ESU&n=6993#yXvlDkSAtyr2Ssar (access date: 10.10.2021) (in Russ.).

75. Sergeev, Yu. D., Mokhov, A. A. (2007). Fundamentals of medical law of Russia, tutorial. Moscow, Meditsinskoe informatsionnoe agentstvo (in Russ.).

76. Groisman, V. A. (2004). Managing the quality of medical aid. Standards and Quality, 4, 100–103 (in Russ.).

77. D'yachenko, V. G., Pushkar', V. A. (2004). System analysis of the quality of medical services rendered to women in the MPI of the Far-East Railroads. Dal'nevostochnyi meditsinskii zhurnal, 3, 17–20 (in Russ.).

78. Akopov, V. I. (2001). On the history of judicial liability of doctors. Nauchno-kul'turologicheskii zhurnal,10, 37–39 (in Russ.).

79. Decree of the All-Russian Central Executive Committee of 01.06.1922 (edition of 25.08.1924) “On introducing the Criminal Code of the RSFSR” (together with the “Criminal Code of the RSFSR”). http://www.consultant.ru/cons/cgi/online.cgi?req=doc&base=ESU&n=3006#sUMlDkSiaKPmX6381 (access date: 10.10.2021) (in Russ.).

80. Decree of the All-Russian Central Executive Committee of 22.11.1926 “On introducing the Criminal Code of the RSFSR in the 1926 edition” (together with the “Criminal Code of the RSFSR”). http://www.consultant.ru/cons/cgi/online.cgi?req=doc&base=ESU&n=3274&dst=100001#9LxkDkSGEYXSdqI (access date: 10.10.2021) (in Russ.).

81. Decree of the USSR Central Executive Committee No. 65, Council of the USSR People’s Commissariate No. 1134 of 27.06.1936 “On prohibition of abortions, increasing fiancial aid to the women recently confined, establishing state aid for large families, broadening the network of maternity hopitals,nurseries and kindergartens, aggravating criminal penalty for nonpayment of alimony, and some changes in the legislation on divorce”. http://www.consultant.ru/cons/cgi/online.cgi?req=doc&base=ESU&n=4068#bH2GtiSUpaYzVL5s (access date: 10.10.2021) (in Russ.).

82. Gesse, E. R., Girgolav, S. S., Shaak, V. A. (eds). Errors, dangers and unforeseen complications when treating surgical diseases: tutorial for doctors. In 4 vol. Leningrad; Moscow, Biomedgiz. Leningr. otd-nie, 1936–1937 (Leningrad: tip. “Pechatnyi dvor” im. A. M. Gor'kogo i tip. “Komintern”). Vol. 1 (in Russ.).

83. Adopted by the People’s Commissariate for Healthcare of the Russian Soviet Federal Socialist Republic in coordination with the RSFSR Prosecutor on February 16, 1934, No. 47/39. (1934). Sovetskaya Yustitsiya, 26, 19 (in Russ.).

84. Barinov, E. Kh., Ochirova, M. A. (2013). Historic aspects of judicial liability of doctors in the first half of the 20th century. Glavnyi vrach: Khozyaistvo i parvo, 4, 41–44 (in Russ.).

85. Akopov, V. I. (2002). To the history of doctor’s legal responsibility and forensic medicine examination in the cases of medical help mistakes. Problemy ekspertizy v meditsine, 2, 1 (5), 3–8 (in Russ.).

86. Sergeev, Yu. D. (2008). Medical law. In 3 vol., tutorial, Moscow, GEOTAR-Media (in Russ.).

87. Criminal Code of the Russian Soviet Federal Socialist Republic (adopted by the Supreme Soviet of the Russian Federation on 27.10.1960) (edition of 30.07.1996). http://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_2950/ (access date: 10.10.2021) (in Russ.).

88. Law of the USSR of 19.12.1969 No. 4589-VII “On adopting the Fundamentals of the legislation of the Union of SSR and the Union republics on healthcare”. http://www.consultant.ru/cons/cgi/online.cgi (access date: 10.10.2021) (in Russ.).

89. Erofeev, S. V., Novoselov, V. P. (2008). Unfavorable outcome of medical aid: study of the problem in forensic medicine. Forensic Medical Expertise, 51 (1), 35–38 (in Russ.).

90. Law of the Russian Soviet Federal Socialist Republic of 29.07.1971 “On healthcare”. http://www.consultant.ru/cons/cgi/online.cgi?req=doc&base=ESU&n=2162#pFI5ViSMxicuy2p51 (access date: 15.10.2021) (in Russ.).

91. Galkin, R. A., Leshchenko, I. G. (2008). Errors in surgical practice and their prevention, monograph. Samara, OOO “IPK “Sodruzhestvo” (in Russ.).

92. Kosukhina, O. I. (2012). To the history of legal liability of doctors for their professional crimes (summary). Medical Anthropology and Bioethics, 2 (4), 1–7 (in Russ.).

93. Bobrov, O. E. (2003). Medical crimes: truth and lies. Petrozavodsk, IntelTek (in Russ.).

94. Kusherbaev, S. K. (2009). Russia needs an overall reform of medical care. Meditsinskoe parvo, 4, 6–9 (in Russ.).

95. Fundamentals of the Russian legislation on health protection of citizens (adopted by the Supreme Soviet of the Russian Federation on 22.07.1993 No. 5487-1) (edition of 07.12.2011). http://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_2413/ (access date: 10.10.2021) (in Russ.).

96. Federal Law “On the fundamentals of heath protection in the Russian Federation” of 21.11.2011 No. 323-FZ (last edition). http://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_121895 (access date: 10.10.2021) (in Russ.).

97. Criminal Code of the Russian Federation of 13.06.1996 No. 63-FZ (edition of 01.07.2021) (with amedments and additions, enacted on 22.08.2021). http://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_10699/ (access date: 10.10.2021) (in Russ.).