Judicial discretion in criminal law policy. Changing the category of a crime by the court

Objective: to study the issue of the optimal scale of judicial discretion in Russian criminal legislation and to develop scientifically grounded proposals for improving legal regulation in this area.

Methods: dialectical materialism, which involves combining a dialectical approach to cognition of the surrounding world with its materialistic understanding, and general scientific (system-structural and formal-logical, inductive and deductive, analysis and synthesis) and special (formal-legal, comparative-legal) methods of cognition based on it.

Results: the problem of the limits of judicial discretion in criminal law stems from the legislator’s attempt to regulate the broad and diverse public relations by legal norms. Given the emerging law enforcement practice, the doctrinal view on the need to “narrow” the limits of criminality under Part 2 of Article 105 of the Russian Criminal Code is considered debatable. Experts point out that there are no negative consequences of the expanded (since 2015) imposition of a suspended sentence for deliberate serious harm to health, committed with aggravating circumstances. The author opposes the arguments of those who consider Part 6 of Article 15 of the Russian Criminal Code to be a violation of the principles of separation of powers, justice, legality, as well as the norm to be corruption-causing. The proposal is to expand the exemption from criminal liability under Articles 761, 762, 90 of the Russian Criminal Code after decreasing the crime category.

Scientific novelty: the article substantiates the author’s opinion on the differentiation of discretion existing in criminal legislation by nature (legal consequences). As a result, the author argues that the court must have a discretion to change the crime category, and attempts to resolve problems related to the implementation of Part 6 of Article 15 of the Russian Criminal Code.

Practical significance: the formulated conclusions can be used in legislative and law enforcement practice in terms of optimizing judicial discretion, taking into account the goals and objectives of criminal law policy.

1. Aleksandrov, A. I. (2017). Criminal policy in the Russian Federation. Once again about the most important thing. Legal science: history and modernity, 4, 34–44. (In Russ.).

2. Artemenko, N. V., & Shimbareva, N. G. (2019). Applying Part 6 of Article 15 of the Criminal Code: comment of the Plenum ruling. Criminal Law, 4, 4–10. (In Russ.).

3. Babaev, M. M. (2017). Uncertainty and problems of law enforcement. Man: Crime and Punishment, 25(1), 12–19. (In Russ.).

4. Belareva, O. A. (2023). Exemption from criminal liability and punishment after changing the category of crime to a lesser one. Bulletin of the Kuzbass Institute, 1(54), 17–25. (In Russ.). https://doi.org/10.53993/2078-3914/2023/1(54)/17-25

5. Boiko, A. I. (2008). Systemic environment of the criminal law: abstract of the Dr. Sci. (Law) thesis. Moscow. (In Russ.).

6. Boskholov, S. S., & Maksimov, S. V. (2018). Criminal law policy: experience, problems and ways of improvement. Prologue: Law Journal, 3, 8–18. (In Russ.). https://doi.org/10.21639/2313-6715.2018.3.2.

7. Golik, Yu. V., & Korobeev, A. I. (2014). Russian criminal legislation reform: to be or not to be? Lex Russica, XCVII(12), 1399–1410. (In Russ.).

8. Gorban, A. V., & Bereza, O. A. (2021). Release from criminal responsibility as a result of a change of the crime category. Criminal Law, 6(130), 11–18. (In Russ.).

9. Gorbatova, M. A., & Gusman, G. S. (2012). Changing the crime category: issues of law enforcement and retroaction of criminal law. Criminal Law, 5, 43–45. (In Russ.).

10. Dolotov, R. O. (2015). Criminal-legal consequences of applying Part 6 of Article 15 of the Russian Criminal Code by court. Moscow University Bulletin. Series 11: Law, 4, 60–72. (In Russ.).

11. Dubrovin, V. V., & Dubrovina, E. G. (2021). The ratio of exemption from criminal liability and from punishment. Legal Science, 7, 124–126. (In Russ.).

12. Inogamova-Khegai, L. V. (2012). Concept of criminal legislation reform. In Modern criminal policy: searching for the optimal model: works of the 7th Russian Congress of criminal law (May 31 – June 1, 2012) (pp. 88–92). Moscow: Prospect. (In Russ.).

13. Khaidarov, A. A. (2015). Court’s discretion to change the crime category to a less severe one. Zakonnost Journal, 2(964), 38–42. (In Russ.).

14. Korobeev, A. I. (2014). Criminal-legal policy of modern Russia the sphere of law-making: “free in its cause?”. Modern problems of criminal policy: works of International conference (pp. 71–81). (In Russ.).

15. Kulev, A. G., & Kuleva, L. O. (2019). Classification of crimes in designing criminal procedure regulations. Actual Problems of Russian Law, 2(99), 130–137. (In Russ.). https://doi.org/10.17803/1994-1471.2019.99.2.130-137

16. Naumov, A. V. (2009). Issues of codification the Russian criminal legislation: new Criminal Code or new edition of the Code? Criminal Law, 4, 44–48. (In Russ.).

17. Naumov, A. V. (2013). Way of reforming the Russian criminal legislation. Zakony Rossii: opyt, analiz, praktika, 10, 3–11. (In Russ.).

18. Nomokonov, V. A. (2014). Anticriminal policy: from liberalization to radicalization? Bulletin of the Kazan Institute of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, 5(1), 32–36. (In Russ.).

19. Pavlova, L. O. (2024). Defects in judicial practice on changing the category of crime. Acrual Problems of Russian law, 19(1), 119–131. (In Russ.). https://doi.org/10.17803/1994-1471.2024.158.1.119-131

20. Petryanin, A. V., Kulikov, R. S., & Neganov, D. A. (2021). Issues of efficiency and correlation of some courses of modern criminal policy: doctrinal and applied aspects. Legal Science and Practice: Journal of Nizhny Novgorod Academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, 4(52), 70–74. (In Russ.). https://doi.org/10.36511/2078-5356-2020-4-70-74

21. Pobegailo, E. F. (2012). On the deepening crisis of the Russian criminal policy. In A. N. Ilyashenko (Ed.), Modern problems of criminal policy: conference materials: in 2 vol. (Vol. 1, pp. 14–24). (In Russ.).

22. Podroikina, I. A. (2014). On the principles of criminal punishment. Nauka i obrazovanie: khozyajstvo i eсonomika; predprinimatelstvo; pravo i upravlenie, 12(55), 74–77. (In Russ.).

23. Podroikina, I. A. (2017). Theoretical bases of constructing a system of penalties in the Russian criminal legislation: abstract of the Dr. Sci. (Law) thesis. Omsk. (In Russ.).

24. Pudovochkin, Yu. E. (2011). On the forthcoming changes in criminal law (as a doctrinal conclusion for the draft Federal Law No. 559740 ‘On making amendments in the Russian Criminal Code and certain legislative acts of the Russian Federation’). In Modern problems of criminal policy (Vol. 1, pp. 74–75). Krasnodar. (In Russ.).

25. Pudovochkin, Yu. E., & Andrianov, V. K. (2015). Regularities of criminal law: on the problem setting. Courier of Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL)), 7, 10–20. (In Russ.).

26. Rarog, A. I. (2013). Legislative attacks at the bases of criminal law. State and Law, 1, 24–32. (In Russ.).

27. Rarog, A. I. (2015). “Working on mistakes” is the duty of the legislator. State and Law, 4, 65–73. (In Russ.).

28. Skripchenko, N. Yu. (2019). On the issue of changing the category of crime. Rossijskaya Yusticziya, 3, 48–51. (In Russ.).

29. Suverov, S. E. (2023) Application of the norms of the institute of exemption from criminal liability when releasing from punishment. Vestnik of Siberian Law Institute of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, 4(53), 79–83. https://doi.org/10.51980/2542-1735_2023_4_79. (In Russ.).

30. Sharapov, R. D. (2023). Changing the category of crime by the court: law, theory, practice. Siberian Legal Review, 20(1), 77–89. (In Russ.). https://doi.org/10.19073/2658-7602-2023-20-1-77-89

31. Yusupov, M. Yu. (2016). Issues of applying a new type of exemption from criminal liability by imposing a court fine. Criminal Law, 6, 122–128. (In Russ.).

32. Zhevlakov, E. N., Zvecharovskii, I. E., Minskaya, V. S., Naumov, A. V., Reshetova, N. Yu., Savkin, A. V., & Khaliulin, A. G. (2010). Discretion on the criminal law and procedure. Criminal Law, 1, 108–113. (In Russ.).

33. Zorina, E. A., Antonov, A. G., & Vakhmistrova, S. I. (2023). On the question of the application of the norms on exemption from criminal liability by analogy in connection with the change in the category of crime. Modern Scientist, 1, 232–237. (In Russ.).

34. Zvecharovskii, I. E. (2018). Clarifications of the Plenum of the Russian Supreme Court on changing the crime category. Zakonnost Journal, 8(1006), 52–53. (In Russ.).